Blog Education The Market in Focus: How Amazon and Zillow Mortgage Products May Impact Mortgage Prices

The Market in Focus: How Amazon and Zillow Mortgage Products May Impact Mortgage Prices

By Aryne + Dulcinea, August 7, 2018

By Aaron Nawrocki, Capital M Lending

What’s new in the mortgage business in 2018? More of the upward cycle in homebuying and competition for mortgage borrowers like we haven’t seen since 2006. After 10 years of fragmentation, big players are entering the mortgage space. Zillow is rolling out a mortgage provider to go with its real estate arm. Additionally, there are likely rumors that Amazon is working to build its own mortgage platform. Questions abound about what disruption Amazon and Zillow mortgage products may bring.

Historically, mortgages have been among the most regulated financial products. The government acts as a mortgage purchaser (Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac) and as a mortgage insurer (FHA). Along with their support for the mortgage industry comes a very specific set of rules for how mortgages can be originated -– we call this compliance– and an arcane set of rules that determine who gets a mortgage or not – called guidelines.

The “guideline” portion of the mortgage business – how loans are approved – could change with the arrival of these new players. Amazon and Zillow have both made a business of predicting consumer behavior by aggregating and analyzing data. It isn’t a big stretch to imagine them using that type of analysis to develop their own set of metrics for approving loans.

Compare how car loans are originated to how mortgage loans are underwritten and approved. Car loans are typically based on verbal information, heavily credit-based and approved in minutes. The value of the collateral (the car) is determined automatically based on a database of actual sales. The automated underwriting system amalgamates the credit, income and collateral data and analyzes it with an algorithm to determine if the loan will be approved. There is a wide spectrum of terms offered, based on risk. “good” loans get lower interest rates, “risky” but approved loans get higher interest rates.

Mortgage loan approvals are rule-driven – has the borrower been self-employed for two years, is the down payment borrowed, etc. There’s a loose correlation between meeting standardized underwriting criteria and loan performance, but at a micro level, loan decisions are not made based on how “good” a loan is. They’re made based on whether the right boxes are checked. While terms vary somewhat based on credit score, for the most part it’s a pass/fail system. It’s all very 1970.

With these new players entering the market, it’s possible that the next wave of change in the mortgage business will be to integrate big data and change the way mortgage loans are approved and priced. Amazon and Zillow mortgage products could mean quicker, easier loan approvals for the consumer. There would be a wider range of terms that more accurately reflects overall risk and makes mortgages available to riskier borrowers. It’s been just about long enough since 2009 for to see the business cycle open to change. The mortgage business has been among the most resistant to change – but five years ago, who thought you’d get into a stranger’s car instead of a taxi?


Aaron Nawrocki has over 20 years of direct experience overseeing mortgage and loan processes, working to provide clients the market insight and lending expertise required to make informed decisions.


About Us:
Over the course of their professional partnership, Aryne + Dulcinea have helped over 200 clients prosper in their new lives. During this time, they have prided themselves in their top-notch selling abilities, with homes outperforming market standards, consistently exceeding list price while most of their listings sell in under 7 days. Whether you’re looking to buy or sell, Aryne & Dulcinea will work in collaboration to guide you in investing in your future and reaching your real estate goals.

Aryne + Dulcinea

Earth Advantage Principal Broker | Earth Advantage Broker | ADU Specialists | OR


Click here to get to know Aryne + Dulcinea!

Aryne + Dulcinea are full-service, high-producing agents, who understand how to navigate the unique challenges facing the Portland real estate market. The secret to their success is in their professionalism and complementary skill sets. In 2012, Aryne + Dulcinea saw an opportunity to combine their creative and technical wisdom to create a values-driven, full-service agency unlike any other. Expert negotiators and project management mavens with a strong background in creative marketing, Aryne + Dulcinea serve as fierce advocates for their clients. 

Their passion for real estate relates closely to their commitment to the Portland way of life, which entails a dedication to sustainability and appreciation for all things local. As Earth Advantage Brokers and ADU Certified Specialists, Aryne + Dulcinea are savvy in all aspects of alternative living practices—from versatile housing additions, green building practices, and revenue-generating strategies. Whether you’re looking to buy or sell, Aryne & Dulcinea will work in collaboration to guide you in investing in your future and reaching you real estate goals.

Aryne greets working with clients throughout Portland with open arms. Licensed since 2005, she appreciates the ever shifting desires her clients have as they move through their real estate goals. Investigative genius on her side, Aryne will strive to bring you the results you desire.  When not working for you, Aryne is a constant cheerleader for her son and daughter’s pursuits on the basketball court and on the ballet stage! She practices yoga, hikes, loves to walk and explore Portland neighborhoods, reads, and delights in soaking up everything Portland has to offer! 

Dulcinea thrives on working with clients with a range of real estate goals.  Oregon born, with a design and an award-winning professional background, Dulcinea is steadfast when it comes to working for her clients and has a keen eye for properties that best serve client objectives. Licensed since 2013, Dulcinea works in and around Portland.  A mother of two and wife to her high school sweetie—in her free time she stays busy with her family, travel, community activism, exploring the outdoors, curating art shows, and dreaming big!

Read More
  • T: 503-380-5124
  • F: 503-961-8224

You might also enjoy

How Living Room’s Health Insurance Saves Brokers Money and Brings Them Peace of Mind


All licensed Living Room brokers automatically qualify for OAR’s Providence Medical Plan. Here are the stories...

Selling During A Market Shift – A Good Story

Jason & Kristin Anderson

It’s no wonder so many people are nervous to sell in a stabilizing market when we...

Home Buying Like a Boss – a crash course in home buying

Lily Ray Wyss

If you are thinking of buying your first home, or have not bought a home in...

A Thanksgiving Story

Kat Gilpatrick

  A thanksgiving story — not in a traditional, seasonal holiday sense with turkey and stuffing and...